Archive for the ‘Dimming’ Category

California Lighting, Final Thoughts

Wednesday, July 22nd, 2009

All in all, the California Title 24 legislation is pretty progressive. With regard to lighting, it is really focused toward making you think about the lighting in your home. You really have two primary approaches toward lighting your living space: either committing fully to fluorescent lighting or using dimmers throughout your home for energy savings. The state is also clearly looking forward to LED lighting, but frankly the industry isn’t ready to support that yet. However, the rate of growth is so strong it will only be a few more years before that changes.

If you commit to fluorescent lighting remember to consider the color temperature and color rendering index of each lamp. Right now people aren’t accustomed to the way everything appears under fluorescents, but I think in a generation the quality of fluorescent lighting will become our new “normal.” With technological advances the fluorescent and LED sources will improve and either the manufacturers will make them more like natural light or (more likely) we’ll just grow to accept the spectral profiles of those sources.

However, if you aren’t ready to make that leap yet you can use dimming systems. I think everyone should use dimming in their homes even if they don’t care at all about energy efficiency, since I believe the quality of life benefits shouldn’t be ignored.

And instead of just using local dimmers, hopefully this will stimulate the use of wider-ranging lighting systems. System that enable you to program lighting for entire rooms rather than just adjusting each circuit. There are countless options out there so don’t feel limited by the adoption of more stringent energy efficiency standards as they progress from the west coast eastward.

California Lighting, Special Rooms

Monday, July 20th, 2009

Special Rooms-Kitchen:

The biggest and most complex part of the lighting section of California’s Title 24 is with regard to kitchen lighting. You are allowed to use a combination of high and low efficacy fixtures in the kitchen because the state considers the visual requirements in the kitchen to be so much more complex than in the rest of the home.

You can use low efficacy fixtures (only in the kitchen) with a combined wattage not to exceed the combined wattage of high efficacy fixtures also in the kitchen. That means if you install 150 watts of high efficacy fluorescent lighting in the kitchen you are also allowed to install up to 150 watts of low efficacy incandescent, halogen, or low-voltage lighting.

Lighting built into cabinets is excluded because it has its own rules, but those built-ins must only light the inside of the cabinet. Lighting attached to the outside of the cabinets does not count as cabinet lighting, but must be included as part of the kitchen wattage calculation. The same goes if you have lighting inside your cabinet but it is designed to light surfaces outside of the cabinet. That is, you can’t install one of the low-voltage striplights that has little MR-16 attachments to point onto your counters to try to get around the kitchen wattage restrictions.

The high efficacy and low efficacy lighting in the kitchen must be controlled separately. (Actually, that is true everywhere, but since you can’t use low efficacy fixtures unless they are dimmed the distinction is a little pointless. You can’t combine different source types on a dimmer, so you couldn’t dim both incandescent and fluorescent fixtures on one control. I guess the only way to mix would be if all of them were on a vacancy sensor, but you shouldn’t be mixing fixture types in any room in which you want to use vacancy sensors anyway.)

To calculate the wattage of the low efficacy fixtures you must use the highest wattage allowed by the fixture. That means you can’t “save” by putting a smaller light bulb in the fixture, say a 60 watt bulb in a fixture that can take up to 100 watts. If you are using low-voltage fixtures you have to use the input wattage of the transformer, which is most likely going to be higher than the wattage of the lamp or lamps.

If you want to use track lighting in your kitchen there are a number of different ways to calculate the wattage against your allowance, but the easiest is just to use 45 watts per foot of track, unless the actual lamping is greater. Yep, a three foot section of track over your island counts as 135 watts, even if you just put two dinky 20 watt pendants on the track. If instead you put three 75 watt incandescent lamps you would have to use the higher combined wattage of 225.

The state has also figured you might try to get around the restriction by running your wiring to boxes and then not hooking up any fixture until after the inspection is complete. So each electrical box either covered by a blank plate or where there isn’t any electrical equipment hooked up counts as 180 watts of low efficacy power toward your allotment. Actually, this is often done innocently when you are going to install a ceiling fan but it hasn’t been picked out yet. The electrician runs the wires to a box that will someday support the fan for you, but he may be done and off the job before the final fan selection is made if you are going to install the fan yourself.

Finally, if you have a kitchen that seamlessly merges into your breakfast nook or any other room you have to be careful with the control wiring. If it looks like a single room the nook will be counted as part of the kitchen unless the lights are controlled by different switches/dimmers/whatever.

Other rooms:

The restrictions for bathrooms, attached and detached garages, laundry rooms,closets, and utility rooms are tighter than for the rest of the home. All the fixtures in all of these rooms must be high efficacy. There are only two exceptions: one, you can use permanently installed low efficacy fixtures if the control is a vacancy sensor; or two, if the closet is less than 70 square feet you can have permanently installed low efficacy fixtures without a vacancy sensor.

Notably missing from the exceptions for these rooms is the exception for using dimmers. As a personal point, I am sorry this is the case since I think that it is pretty important to dim the lights in the bathroom. See my post on dimmers in the bathroom for the reasons why. And if you have dimmed incandescent or halogen fixtures throughout your home I think it is poor design to use dimmed fluorescent in the bathroom.

California Lighting, Overview

Thursday, July 16th, 2009

California has recently adopted energy efficiency standards that have a huge impact upon lighting. And since California has been leading the country in energy efficiency standards I thought I’d write up a quick summary of what homeowners ought to know about the changes to residential lighting since it is just a matter of time before similar rules spread to the rest of the country. Note that there are a couple adoption dates that we haven’t reached yet, so the entire Title 24 code isn’t in effect as of right now, but we may as well look to the future.

First of all, the new rules apply to all new residences and other projects that require a permit, so chances are you’re going to have to comply. Portable lighting, such as table and floor lamps, are not covered by the changes. However, all permanent lighting is covered and that basically includes anything attached to a surface. So you can’t stick a lighting track on the ceiling but control it by a cord plugged into an outlet. Lighting installed in furniture like cabinets or bath vanities is included. The big exception to this is lighting that is built into appliances, such as microwaves, refrigerators or stove exhaust hoods.

The idea is to divide lighting fixtures into high efficacy and low efficacy groups. You can install all the high efficacy fixtures you want anywhere you want. (Interestingly, to divide the fixtures into high and low efficacy the rules use just the lamp efficiency, rather than the actual fixture efficacy. Remember the efficiency/efficacy post?) To determine if a fixture is high efficacy it must comply with the following lumens per watt limits.

  • If the fixture’s lamp is 5 watts or less, it must get at least 30 lumens per watt.
  • If the fixture’s lamp is up to 15 watts, it must get at least 40 lumens per watt.
  • If the fixture’s lamp is up to 40 watts, it must get at least 50 lumens per watt.
  • If the fixture’s lamp is over 40 watts, it must get at least 60 lumens per watt.

(However, the method to determine the lumens per watt of LED fixtures has some restrictions so you can’t use the LPW of the LED module. You have to use the input power of the LED driver, but then it must also comply with the same LPW restrictions as above. You do NOT have to take the ballast for fluorescent lamps into account.)

Anything that doesn’t meet the above LPW restrictions is considered a low efficacy fixture.

In addition, there are some things that will automatically classify fixtures as a low efficacy fixture, the most important being that anything with a screw base socket is considered low efficacy. That means all fixtures using the medium or candelabra size socket that all our fixtures in our homes have been using for decades. There are some other things but the screw base socket is the most important. There is an exception for HID lamps with screw base sockets, and a huge section regarding the GU-24 base, but you probably won’t have to be concerned with those details.

Now, once you know what is high efficacy or low efficacy you can figure out what you can install in your home. There is a complex exception for the kitchen, but the basic rule of thumb is that you can only use high efficacy fixtures in your home.

Now, there are exceptions for most of your living areas:

  1. Low efficacy fixtures may be used if the circuit is controlled by a “vacancy sensor.” This is not the same as an occupancy sensor! A vacancy sensor is defined by the state as a control that can only be turned on manually and will automatically turn itself off after a preset time of 30 minutes or less unless it detects that the room is occupied or if the control is turned off manually. This explicitly excludes controls that turn on automatically, which is how occupancy sensors typically work. Also, if the control has a switch or something that allows you to choose if the turn on method is manual or automatic, it does not count.
  2. Low efficacy fixtures may be used if the circuit is controlled by a dimmer. The dimmer can be one that has several steps instead of a continuous sliding range, however, the dimmer must reduce the energy use by at least 65% at its lowest setting. That means that two-level switches with three settings (off, 1/2,  and full on) do not count. Three-level switches which have four settings (off, 1/3, 2/3, and full on) do count. Also, if the dimming circuit can be controlled from multiple locations it must be impossible to bypass the dimmer. The alternate locations can either be remote dimmers or switches that turn the lights either off or to the dimmed level only.

There are exceptions and additions, most notably in the kitchen. However, it’s fairly involved so I’ll address them in the next post.

Residential Fluorescent Lighting

Tuesday, July 14th, 2009

So, yesterday I posted a process I might go through to replace a fixture in my home with something more energy efficient. However, it isn’t really what I would do in my own home because I like everything to be dimmed. That includes fluorescents.

A good number of fluorescent and compact fluorescents can be dimmed using dimming ballasts. That does NOT include the self-ballasted CFLs with the screw-in base that you find at the hardware store. GE has come out with a self-ballasted replacement CFL that can be dimmed, and I’m sure others either have or will have soon their own versions. However, these can only be dimmed about 50% before they just turn off. They aren’t worth it.

Instead, I would have to buy separate dimming ballasts and install them myself. I would also have to change out my dimmers to a special versions for fluorescent lighting or perhaps install an interface. Some fluorescent dimming is done using two-wire ballasts, which would be easier to install using existing wiring, but the better dimming is accomplished using three-wire ballasts, which requires a third connection between the dimmer or interface and the ballast.

Fluorescent dimming ballasts typical have a minimum power setting of 1%, 5%, or 10%. For residential use I always recommend using 1% ballasts. This is because reducing the power doesn’t look like the same amount of light reduction. If you dim fluorescents down to a 10% it looks like it has only been dimmed down to about 30%. This just isn’t low enough for use in homes. Instead, using a 1% ballast means the lighting will look like it has been reduced to about 10%.

Three-Way Dimming

Tuesday, June 23rd, 2009

Yesterday, at the end of the post, I mentioned three-way and four-way dimming. For local dimmers there are two approaches: “mechanical,” and “electronic.” Mechanical and electronic refer to the dimmer type. Electronic dimmers are labeled as such and usually have LEDs on them. Mechanical dimmers are cheaper and will have no special functions and usually have a rotating dial or a slider.

For mechanical three and four way dimmers you will have to select a single location to install the dimmer, which should typically be the place from which you control the light most often. All the other locations will still be a switch that just turns the light on or off, and when turned on the lights go to the level set by the dimmer. For both three-way and four-way circuits you only use a three-way dimmer. It will have three wires instead of two (excluding the green ground wire).

Electronic dimming allows you to use remote dimmers in those locations that otherwise would have had to stay switches. However, installation is much more complex because typically there is a low-voltage wire connecting all the dimmers together. If your house doesn’t already have that wire you’re pretty much out of luck. You can use radio-controlled dimmers to eliminate the need for those extra wires, but the cost is very high (hundreds of dollars per item). Some electronic dimmer also let you use IR remote controls, and sometimes you can tie your master remote for the TV/DVD to the lights. That way you can adjust the lighting just the same as adjusting the volume on your TV. You’ll probably need to hire an electrician for those kinds of installations.

Installing All Those Dimmers!

Monday, June 22nd, 2009

I realized that last week did a good job covering the basics of how to use dimmers in the home, but not about the doing-it-yourself part. You don’t need to hire someone to put dimmers in your home.

From the safety perspective, find the breaker in your panel that controls the power to the light you want to dim and turn it off. With cellphones and cheap two-way radios, you probably don’t even need to yell across the house anymore!

The only tool you’ll need is a screwdriver. The dimmer will use Phillips head screws, but your faceplate may be attached with a standard slotted screw if the home is older. Keep the old screws that attach the faceplate to the box in the wall, but the dimmer will probably have new screws for the dimmer.

The dimmer will include instructions that has pictures as well as text in english and spanish (for the most part). The key is to keep track of the wires that were already attached to the switch! There will most likely be a black and a white wire–or two black wires–connected to the switch, and you just connect the black and white wires on the dimmer to the wires in the wall. Truth be told, it doesn’t matter which is which.

The dimmer package will also contain a couple wire nuts to attach the wires. Some dimmers have holes that you can just shove the wires into for a solid connection, but if not use the wire nuts. Twist the two wires together like a twisty-tie, but it doesn’t have to be real tight. Then just twist the wire nut on, just like a screw-driver (right-makes-tight).

The dimmer will also have a green wire for the ground. There probably won’t be a green wire in the box to connect it to, but it can be attached to the bare metal of the box.

Finally, when you are totally done, check to make sure you didn’t install the dimmer upside down! The slider or rocker should make the lights brighter when you move or press UP and lower when you press DOWN. If the dimmer includes a toggle, up is on and down is off. For a rotary style dimmer it doesn’t matter. Some dimmers have the name of the manufacturer somewhere on the face, which is an easy way to make sure it’s not upside down before turning the power back on.

(Aside, dimmers for three-way switching are more complex and not covered here. A three-way switch is where you can turn the lights on and off from two locations. A four-way switch is where you can turn the lights on and off from three or more locations.)

Dimmers Throughout the Home

Friday, June 19th, 2009

Lastly, all the others places in the home are when most people start with dimmers instead of ending with them. The dining room, living room, family room, etc. are good places to create the warm family home most people enjoy. Those are often the first places people think to install dimmers since they think of those areas as more “public.” I agree, and since those rooms get used so much they are great places to install dimmers. But if you can’t afford or want to buy dimmers for every room in your house you should leave these rooms until the next round of dimmers and just focus on the rooms discussed in the last few posts.

Dimmers in the Kitchen

Thursday, June 18th, 2009

The kitchen is an odd sort of place when it comes to dimming. You need to have lots of light for preparing meals, so it would seem to be a place you could skip. However, the kitchen is also a place where many people tend to congregate. To that end, your dimmer will receive much more of a workout, but you’ll end up finding you use it all the time. It becomes a more comfortable gathering place when dimmed, and you’ll find yourself only cracking it up to full to prepare a big meal. Most of the time it will be dimmed down some.

Note that some newer homes have fluorescent lights installed in the kitchen to really pump up the light levels for cooking. If you have a fluorescent light in the kitchen, you’ll need to refer to my postings about fluorescent dimming, which I haven’t written yet. Be on the lookout.

Dimmers in the Bathroom

Wednesday, June 17th, 2009

Dimming in the bathroom is just as important as dimming in the bedroom. In addition to helping you get to sleep–as an extension of dimming in the bedroom–it can help you wake up in the morning more gently. We all know that flipping on the switch snaps us awake. Instead, if we start with a low level of light and continue bumping it up to full our body can ease into waking. I have found that having the same amount of sleep, I feel more refreshed when I ease into the morning.

Also, if you get up in the middle of the night for any reason being able to keep the lights in the bathroom low will make it easier to fall back asleep again.

As a final, cosmetic note, when getting ready for an evening out you should try to prepare yourself in same quality of light as the place you are going. If you’re going to a club or a nice restaurant, the lighting in those places will be dimmed, and you want to know what you’ll look like when you get there. Getting ready under full brightness is great for the daytime or office, but evenings out needs something special.

Dimming Your Bedroom

Tuesday, June 16th, 2009

One of the most important–and most commonly overlooked–places to use dimmers is your bedroom. During the day, having the lights on at full blast works fine. But in the evenings, the lower level of lighting not only creates a more calm and relaxed environment, but it actually gets your body ready to sleep. I start with my lights dimmed to about one-half, and as I go through the bedtime routine I keep bumping the lights lower and lower. By the time I’m ready to actually get in bed the lights are around 10-20% of full.

This can be especially useful to help children fall asleep. If the bedtime routine with your kids is tough, try to make sure that they stay out of rooms fully lit. This is especially true if they get out of bed and run into a fully lit hallway. The bright light jolts the body into a waking state. If you start lowering the lighting before the bedtime routine begins, and keep lowering it throughout, they will be physically synced into a nighttime rhythm. It won’t solve the issue completely, but it will help make other methods more effective.